Microsoft word - newsletter for august, 2009 - ptsd.doc
Westwood Evaluation & Treatment Center, 11340 Olympic Boulevard, Suite 303,
Los Angeles, California 90064, 310-444-3154, [email protected]
“in order to diagnose a Posttraumatic Stress
Disorder correctly the doctor must show that the
individual meets the DSM-IV-TR criteria”
One of the most frequently encountered diagnoses in personal injury and workers’ compensation litigation is a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (309.81).
Clearly, not everyone who has been exposed to the
According to the DSM-IV-TR, a Posttraumatic Stress
type of stressors that can produce a Posttraumatic Stress
Disorder is diagnosed correctly when an individual has been
Disorder will invariably develop such a disorder. For
exposed to an extreme life-threatening traumatic stressor that
example, knowing that someone was exposed to a major
has led to the development of a set of characteristic signs
automobile accident does not necessarily mean they will
and/or symptoms that have lasted more than one month. These
develop a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. In this regard,
extreme life-threatening stressors may involve actual or
research has shown that only somewhere between 10%
threatened death, a serious injury, a threat to one’s physical
and 45% of individuals who have survived a serious
integrity, witnessing such an event, or learning that a family
automobile accident will develop a Posttraumatic Stress
member or close associate has experienced such an event.
Such traumatic events include, but are not limited to,
Similarly, the magnitude of a traumatic event is not a
military combat, violent or personal sexual and/ or physical
perfect predictor of its psychological effect. Thus, what
assaults that may occur during robberies or muggings, being
may appear to be a relatively “mild” stressor may have a
kidnapped, being taken hostage, terrorist attacks, torture,
great effect on a given individual. The variables
incarceration as a prisoner of war, natural or manmade
responsible for differential effects of the same stressor on
disasters, severe automobile accidents or being diagnosed with
different people have been researched and it is known
a life-threatening illness. Witnessed events include, but are not
that factors that may predispose one to develop a
limited to, observing a serious injury or the unnatural death of
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder include childhood trauma,
another person due to a traumatic event such as a major
chronic adversity, and familial stressors. In general,
accident, a violent assault, a natural disaster, or an act of war.
physical proximity to the event, the length of the
A Posttraumatic Stress Disorder can also be produced by
exposure, the severity of the trauma, and an interpersonal
learning that one’s child has a life-threatening illness.
trauma also appear more likely to result in the development of a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder.
Although between 50% and 90% of the population in the United States will experience a traumatic event of a type that
As noted below, a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
can cause a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, research indicates
cannot be diagnosed during the month following the
that only 8% of the population will experience such a disorder
trauma since research indicates that many of the
during their lifetime. The highest rates of occurrence are
symptoms a person experiences during that first month
among rape victims, combat veterans and individuals who have
are normal. These symptoms may include sleep
been targeted for political imprisonment or genocide.
disturbances, a loss of concentration, anxiety, depression, guilt, anger, irritability, hypervigilance, flashbacks, and disturbances in social, occupational or educational
Most importantly, in order to diagnose a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder correctly the doctor must show that the
individual meets the DSM-IV-TR criteria that are given
A. The person has been exposed to an extreme life-
(7) The individual has a sense of having a
threatening traumatic event in which both of the
shortened future as shown by expectations
such as the belief that they will not have a
normal life span, career, and/or family.
(1) The person experienced, witnessed, or was in
some other way confronted with an event in
D. The individual shows persistent signs and/or
which there was an actual or threatened death or
symptoms of increased arousal as indicated by two
serious injury to him or herself or others.
(2) The person responded to this event with intense
(1) Difficulty initiating or maintaining sleep.
(2) Irritability and/or outbursts of anger.
B. The experience of the traumatic event has been
persistently re-experienced in at least one of the
(4) Hypervigilance or a state of exaggerated
oversensitivity to a class of events the
(1) Distressing recollections of the event that are
(5) An exaggerated startle response, which is an
(2) Distressing and recurrent dreams of the event.
(3) Acting and/or feeling as if the traumatic event
were recurring, including flashbacks of the event
E. The disturbances noted above have been present
in which the person may feel cut off from the
(4) When exposed to events and/or thoughts and
F. The disturbances noted above cause clinically
feelings that resemble and/or symbolize the
significant distress and/or impairment in social,
event, they experience intense psychological
occupational and/or other important areas of
(5) When exposed to events and/or thoughts and
feelings that resemble and/or symbolize the
Posttraumatic Stress Disorders can be diagnosed with
event, they experience intense physical signs
“specifiers.” Specifiers further describe the precise
nature of the disorder’s presentation. “Acute” can be
specified if the disorder has been present for less than
C. The individual persistently avoids stimuli associated
three months. “Chronic” is the specifier used if the
with the trauma and/or there is a numbing of their
disorder has been present for three months or more.
general responsiveness, as shown by the presence of
“With Delayed Onset” is specified if the onset of the
signs and symptoms of the disorder occurred six months
or longer after the stressor. “In Partial Remission” is the
(1) The individual makes an effort to avoid
specifier used if the full criteria for the disorder were
thoughts, feelings, and/or conversations
previously met, but at the time of the doctor’s evaluation
only some of the signs or symptoms remain. “In Full
(2) The individual makes an effort to avoid
Remission” is the specifier used if there are no longer
activities, places, and/or people that bring back
any signs or symptoms of the disorder but the disorder’s
presence in the past is of clinical interest.
(3) The individual displays an inability to recall an
In conducting a psychological evaluation to determine
(4) The individual shows a marked diminished
if someone has a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder the doctor
interest and/or participation in significant
must follow the normal psychodiagnostic procedures by:
activities that they previously engaged in.
(5) The individual feels detached and/or estranged
2. taking a complete life history including the
(6) The individual has a restricted range of affect or
patient’s complaints or, as they are sometimes
3. administering a battery of objective psychological
With respect to psychotherapy, a variety of
approaches such as exposure therapy and cognitive therapy have been shown to be effective in the
4. reading the available medical records to see what
treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorders. In this
other mental health practitioners have found
regard, exposure therapy involves helping the patient
5. obtaining collateral sources of information in the
confront their distressing memories in order to
form of interviews with the patient’s relatives,
facilitate what is called habituation, desensitization
or adaptation. Simply put, habituation, desensitization or adaptation are different terms that
Once a Posttraumatic Stress Disorder has been
all mean that the ability of the memory, and the
diagnosed correctly the treatment usually consists of a
neurological residual of the traumatic experience to
combination of medication and psychotherapy. In this
produce symptoms, has been blunted. This blunting
regard, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI’s)
typically is produced by exposing the patient to
such as Celexa, Lexapro, Prozac, Luvox, Paxil and Zoloft
thoughts and images of the stressful experience or
as well as tricyclic antidepressants such as Elavil,
by using in vivo exposures at the trauma’s site.
Anafranil, Sinequan, Tofranil, Pamelor and Vivactil have
been shown to be effective in reducing the patient’s
Similarly, cognitive therapy helps the victim
symptoms although they are rarely sufficient in
restructure the meaning they attribute to the
themselves to produce a complete remission.
experience and re-organize their memory of the trauma by helping them to assess the traumatic
experience in a more integrated and less distressing
manner. This treatment may also require in vivo
exposures at the trauma’s site and often uses
relaxation techniques to reduce the patient’s adverse
reaction to the trauma-related cues and to desensitize
or harden them to their anxiety or fears.
____________________________________________________________________________________
This is the seventh of a series of monthly newsletters aimed at
providing information about psychological evaluations and
treatment that may be of interest to attorneys and insurance
February, 2009 –Litigation problems with the GAF
adjusters working in the areas of workers’ compensation and
March, 2009 – Common flaws in psych reports
personal injury. If you have not received some or all of our past
April, 2009 – The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality
newsletters, and would like copies, send us an email requesting
the newsletter(s) that you would like forwarded to you.
May, 2009 – Apportioning psychiatric disability in workers’ compensation cases and assessing aggravation in personal injury cases June, 2009 - Subjectively interpreted projective psychological tests July, 2009 – Sleep disorders and psychiatric injuries
The Method – New and old Technology Assessment methods Serious game How far would you go to become stronger, fitter or more competitive? Ritalin for your child to improve its educational chances? A robotic arm to boost strength? With the Rathenau Instituut’s new human enhancement app you can put your ethics to the test. spend time in training or use enhancements – mild and rad